Ranking of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu using WISER and PRIMOEX: An Analytical Study
Abstract
This Study examines and explores through a web metric ranking analysis of the websites of 22 state universities in Tamil Nadu. It discussed the domain systems of the websites; WISER Web ranking for the year 2016 and 2017. Similarly, the researchers manipulated a new ranking tools for ranking the websites of State universities of Tamil Nadu, According to WISER ranking, Anna University is ranked first with 2469.4 WISER value followed by Tamil Nadu Agricultural University which is ranked second with 4031.4 WISER value. University of Madras is ranked third with 4333.8 WISER values in the year 2017. But when we used the PRIMOEX ranking, Anna University is ranked first with 3653.3 PRIMOEX value followed by Tamil Nadu Agricultural University which is ranked second with 4090.6 PRIMOEX value. Madurai Kamaraj University is ranked third with 4136.1 PRIMOEX values. Alagappa University is ranked fourth with 4956.1 PRIMOEX value and Alagappa University with 6001.9 PRIMOEX value is ranked fifth. It found that PRIMOEX good tool to measure the ranking of websites of state universities of Tamil Nadu.
Keywords:
Webometric Analysis, Ranking of Websites, WISER, PRIMOEX, State Universities, Tamil Nadu1. Introduction
Metric studies when applied on the information provide more insights about the information. The metric studies help to identify the knowledge gap in a particular field. It provides new ideas about the information and promotes new researches. Metric studies are the boon to the library and information science which gives information about information and the metric study field in library and information science will definitely evolve more in the future. The websites of institutions have become one of the main sources of information in academic and research activities. In terms of research, educational institutions’ websites can announce the existence and promote the achievements of individuals, research groups, institutions and departments. They can also disseminate findings, either by hosting online articles or publishing summaries, data sets or tools. The pages themselves can be created centrally, by administrators or webmasters, or logically by individuals for themselves or their research team projects. Potential benefits of an effective web presence include greater research impact, attracting students, media interest and commercial contacts.
2. Webometrics & Literature Review
2.1 Webometrics
The Webometrics defined as using the techniques of bibliometric in order to study the relationship of different sites on the World Wide Web. Such techniques may also be used to map out areas of the Web that appear to be most useful or influential, based on the number of times they are hyperlinked to other Web sites. The methods of webometrics are;
According to Björneborn and Ingwersen (2004), the Webometrics study covers the construction side and usage side of the web and it focus on the four main areas such as:
- • Web page content analysis, Web link structure analysis (e.g. Hyperlink, Self link, External link and Inlink);
- • Web usage analysis (e.g. exploiting log files for users searching and browsing behaviour); and
- • Web technology analysis (including search engine performance).
Therefore, Webometrics is the quantitative study of web-related phenomena, originated in the realisation that methods originally designed for bibliometric analysis.
2.2 Literature Review
Huntington, Nicholas, and Jamali (2008) explained that Metrics derived from user visits or sessions provide a means of evaluating Websites and an important insight into online information seeking behaviour. The authors argued that page time distribution is composed of a number of quite separate view time distributions because of the marked differences in view times between pages. The web application of product, usage and development of document-centric, interactive usability, Graphic User Interfaces had been explained by Kastania and Zimeras (2010). They classified the websites by three methods such as the web typology or digital business models, the ‘stages of development’ models and the use of scoring system. Each had been explained with its stages and sub methods. Moreover, the usability of web applications by response times, interaction efficiency, colours, text layout page structure, navigation structure, multiculturalism etc had been brought out. The exploratory methods, analytic methods and experimental method had been specified to evaluate the usability of web application.
Bowler, Hong, and He (2011) analyzed the Six Health Websites’ Visibility in order to know about website which had provided reliable health information. Google webmaster tool was used to gather inlinks and were classified by the type of creator. The study found that the weak network of inlinks led to lost opportunity to the health care people, to young people. Also, it generated that the Google webmaster inlink tool did not guaranteed for 100 percent coverage and some inlinks were not captured by the tool. Iroaganachi et al. (2016) assessed the quantity of research publication within the period, top ten published universities, fields, journals and their impact factors, cited authors, and top ten published countries. This was with a view to determining author relevance, institutional priority, the extent of sustainable development in the fields and host countries.
Govindarajan and Dhanavandan (2016) Found that the analysis gives interesting insights about the associations’ websites. All India Ophthalmic Society (AIOS) is the most popular website and is in the first place among all the associations’ website. It holds the global rank of 965269. Chandigarh Ophthalmologist website holds the highest bounce rate of 82.0. Thelwall et al. (2016) analyses a range of altmetric and webometric indicators in terms of suitability for funding scheme evaluations, compares them to traditional indicators and reports some statistics derived from a pilot study with Welcome Trust-associated publications. It founds that the dome alternative indicators have advantages to usefully complement scientometric data by reflecting a different type of impact or through being available before citation data. Varadharajalu and Dhanavandan (2017) discusses why External Web Impact Factor (EWIF) is more meaningful than simple WIF. The study also attempts the websites of Telangana State Universities by considering website ranking systems and compares the WIF and EWIF. It found that the Professor Jayashankar Telangana State Agricultural University ranked 1 (0.0040%) in Selflink Web Impact Factor of State University Websites in Telangana. Palamuru University, and Satavahana University shares 2nd (0.0031) rank in Self Link Web Impact Factor. The Jawaharlal Nehru Technological University ranked as first (0.0007) in External Link Web Impact Factor.
3. Methodology
The main aim of this study is to examine the 22 websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu. The relevant data collected from Alexa, Webometrics, SEO Tools and Google page ranking. It identifies the web domains, WISER and PRIMOEX ranking for the year 2016 and 2017 web ranking. The SPSS were used for the analysis.
3.1 Study Area
This study discusses about the ranking websites of State Universities (Government only) in Tamil Nadu which using the WISER and PRIMOEX. There are various tools are available to measure the websites. There are more number of higher educational intuitions are available in India. Particularly in Tamil Nadu has huge number of higher educational institutions like Central Universities, State Government Universities, Deemed Universities, Technical institutions and others. In these circumstances, the universities are needed to more visibility and attraction by the way of using websites. This study aimed at to examine the 22 websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu. Therefore, it is necessary to rank the websites of educational institutions in the context of competition among them due to privatization of education. The approach taken will be called ranking of websites which covers other quantitative measures like WISER and PRIMOEX.
3.2 Objectives of the Study
The major objectives of the study are:
- 1. To explore the existence of website of State Universities in Tamil Nadu.
- 2. To identify the domain name preferred by the State Universities.
- 3. To identify the types of domain preferred by the State Universities in Tamil Nadu.
- 4. To know the visibility and connectivity of website using WISER Rank
- 5. To provide a rank using PRIMOEX
3.3 Scope and Limitation
There are 22 websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu are alone taken up for the study. The advanced search facility of Alexa Web ranking tool, Webometrics web ranking and Small SEO Tools are used for data collection. The relevant data were collected during the period in 2017. Since the data were dynamic in nature. The Central Universities, Private Universities & Deemed Universities in Tamil Nadu are excluded.
4. Results and Discussion
4.1 State Universities in Tamil Nadu
The University Grants Commission and the State Councils should develop coordinate methods to keep a watch on standards. It is in pursuance of this significant recommendation of the National Education Policy that the Government of Tamil Nadu established a State Council for Higher Education by the Tamil Nadu State Council for Higher Education (TANSCHE) Act. This statutory body started functioning from 9th November 1992. The total number of Universities functioning in the State was 59. Comprising the State Universities 22 and Private Deemed Universities 29. The following Table 1 gives the detailed list of 22 State Universities of Tamil Nadu and their URL address.
4.2 URL Domain of the Universities in Tamil Nadu
The URL domain of the universities were analysed irrespective of website domain. The web domain were identified in under seven category such as ‘.ac.in’, ‘.edu’, ‘.edu.in’, ‘.in’, ‘.info’, ‘.nic.in’ and ‘.org’. The same has been shown in Table 2.
Table 2 states the URL domain wise distribution of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu. It is understood from the table, that most of the State Universities are using ‘.ac.in’ 15 (68.18%) higher than the other domains. The second highest domain ‘.edu.in’ used by 3 (13.64%) the universities and 2 (9.09%) Universities are using the domain ‘.org’ in their Website.
4.3 Discipline wise State Universities in Tamil Nadu
The state universities were analysed irrespective of subject discipline of universities. The discipline were classified such as ‘.Arts Science’, ‘.Engineering & Technology’, ‘Medical’, and Others and it has been shown in Table 3.
The Table 3 shows the subject Discipline wise State Universities in Tamil Nadu. Among the 22, 12 (54.55%) universities comes under ‘Arts & Science’ and 8 (36.36%) universities are in ‘Others’ category which consists of Sports, Education, Agriculture, Music & others. It is pointed out from the table, equally one university from Medical and Engineering & Technology discipline.
4.4 WISER Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for 2016
According to WISER Ranking method, we have taken the four indicators namely Presence (P), Impact (I), Openness (O) and Excellence (E) are collected and different weight age have been given to each indicator to calculate the rank. In this section the WISER Ranking analysis of web sites of universities in Tamil Nadu is analyzed.
Webometric Rank (WR) = 0.1*Presence P+0.5*Impact+0.1*Openness+0.3*Excellence |
The WISER ranking analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for the year 2016 were analyzed in the Table 4.
Table 4 depicts the WISER ranking of websites of state universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 2016. According to WISER ranking, Anna University is ranked first with 1888.3 WISER value followed by Annamalai University which is ranked second with 3145.7 WISER value. University of Madras is ranked third with 3631.5 WISER values. Tamil Nadu Agricultural University is ranked fourth with 3699.7 WISER values and Bharathidasan University with 4043.3 WISER value is ranked fifth. It is also observed that Tamil Nadu National Law School and Tamil Nadu Fisheries University occupy the last two ranks with 13063.1 and 13083.4 WISER value respectively. No data for the Tamil Nadu Music and Fine Arts University in the respective sources.
4.5 WISER Value Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for 2016
The classification of WISER Ranking Analysis of Websites of Universities in Tamil Nadu the overall for the year 2016 were analysed and the same has been shown in Table 5. The WISER Ranking Value were categorized under six different values are such as 0001-5000, 5001-10000, 10001-15000, and 15001and above.
Table 5 describes the classification of WISER Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 2016. Among the 22 universities, 7 (31.82%) universities WISER value is below 5000 and 11 (50.00%) Universities have WISER Value from 5001 to 10000 is higher than other WISER values of ranking. Followed by 3 (13.64%) universities WISER Value ranking is 10001 to 15000. For 1 (4.55%) University have no data from the sources among the website in the state universities in Tamil Nadu for year of 2016.
4.6 WISER Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for 2017
The WISER ranking analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for the year 2017 were analyzed in the Table 6.
Table 6 shows the WISER ranking of websites of state universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 2017. According to WISER ranking, Anna University is ranked first with 2469.4 WISER value followed by Tamil Nadu Agricultural University which is ranked second with 4031.4 WISER value. University of Madras is ranked third with 4333.8 WISER values. Annamalai University is ranked fourth with 4371.5 WISER value and Madurai Kamaraj University with 4958.8 WISER value is ranked fifth. It is also observed that Tamil Nadu Fisheries University and Tamil Nadu National Law School occupy the last two ranks with 13160.0 and 13198.7 WISER value respectively. No data for the Tamil Nadu Music and Fine Arts University in the respective sources.
4.7 WISER Value Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu – 2017
The classification of WISER Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu the overall for the year 2017 were analyzed and the same has been shown in Table 7. The WISER Ranking Value were categorized under six different values are such as 0001-5000, 5001-10000, 10001-15000, and 15001and above.
Table 7 describes the classification of WISER Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 20176. Among the 22 universities, 8 (36.36%) universities are equally in the WISER value is below 5000 and 5001 to 10000 and 10001-15000 is higher than other WISER values of ranking. And 5 (22.72%) universities are in below 5000 WISER value. Followed by 3 (13.64%) universities WISER Value ranking is 10001 to 15000. For 1 (4.55%) University have no data from the sources among the website in the state universities in Tamil Nadu for year of 2017.
4.8 PRIMOEX Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for 2016
According to PRIMOEX Ranking method, we have taken the four indicators namely Presence (P), Impact (I), Openness (O) and Excellence (E) are collected and different weightage have been given to each indicator to calculate the rank. In this section the PRIMOEX Ranking analysis of websites of universities in Tamil Nadu is and the data has been presented
Webometric Rank (WR) = 0.4*Presence +0.3*Imapct+0.2*Openness O+0.1* Excellence |
The PRIMOEX ranking analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for the year 2016 were analyzed in the Table 8.
Table 8 indicates the PRIMOEX ranking of websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 2016. According to PRIMOEX ranking, Anna University is ranked first with 3453.0 PRIMOEX value followed by Tamil Nadu Agricultural University which is ranked second with 3896.7 PRIMOEX value. Annamalai University is ranked third with 3948.8 PRIMOEX values. Alagappa University is ranked fourth with 4046.7 PRIMOEX value and University of Madras with 6140.8 PRIMOEX value is ranked fifth. It is also observed that Tamil Nadu Physical Education and Sports University and Tamil Nadu National Law School occupy the last two ranks with 13846.2 and 15004.9 PRIMOEX value respectively.
4.9 PRIMOEX Value Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for the year 2016
The classification of Inlinks PRIMOEX Ranking Analysis of Websites of Universities in Tamil Nadu the overall for the year 2016 were analyzed and the same has been shown in Table 9. The PRIMOEX Ranking Value were categorized under six different values are such as 0001-5000, 5001-10000, 10001-15000, and 15001and above.
Table 9 describes the classification of PRIMOEX Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 2016. Among the 22 universities, 5 (22.73%) universities PRIMOEX value is below 5000 and 7 (31.82%) Universities have PRIMOEX Value from 10000 to 15000 is higher than other PRIMOEX values of ranking. Followed by 9 (40.90%) universities PRIMOEX Value ranking is between 10001to 15000 and 1 (4.55%) university is in above 15000.
4.10 PRIMOEX Ranking Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for 2017
The PRIMOEX ranking analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for the year 2017 were analyzed in the Table 10.
Table 10 describes the PRIMOEX ranking of websites of state universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 2017. According to PRIMOEX ranking, Anna University is ranked first with 3653.3 PRIMOEX value followed by Tamil Nadu Agricultural University which is ranked second with 4090.6 PRIMOEX value. Madurai Kamaraj University is ranked third with 4136.1 PRIMOEX values. Alagappa University is ranked fourth with 4956.1 PRIMOEX value and Alagappa University with 6001.9 PRIMOEX value is ranked fifth. It is also observed that Tamil Nadu Physical Education and Sports University and Tamil Nadu National Law School occupy the last two ranks with 14980.3 and 15257.8 PRIMOEX value respectively. No data for the Tamil Nadu Music and Fine Arts University in the respective sources.
4.11 PRIMOEX Value Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu for 2017
The classification of Inlinks PRIMOEX Ranking Analysis of Websites of Universities in in Tamil Nadu the overall for the year 2017 were analyzed and the same has been shown in Table 11. The PRIMOEX Ranking Value were categorized under six different values are such as 0001-5000, 5001-10000, 10001-15000, and 15001and above.
Table 11 describes the classification of PRIMOEX value Analysis of Websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu in the year 2017. Among the 22 universities, 4 18.18%) universities PRIMOEX value is below 5000 and 6 (27.27%) Universities have PRIMOEX Value between 5000 and 10000 is higher than other PRIMOEX values of ranking. The 10 (45.45%) Universities are has PRIMOEX Value between 10001 and 15000 is higher than other PRIMOEX values of ranking. Followed by 1 (4.55%) university PRIMOEX Value ranking is 15001 and above. And only one University has no data from the sources among the website in the state universities in Tamil Nadu for year of 2017.
4.12 WISER Vs PRIMOEX Ranking of Websites or 2016 and 2017: Overall Rank
The WISER Vs PRIMOEX ranking of Websites of the State Universities in Tamil Nadu for year 2016 & 2017 overall rank were analyzed and the same has been shown in Table 12.
Table 12 describes the WISER Vs PRIMOEX ranking of Websites of the State Universities in Tamil Nadu for year 2016 & 2017 overall rank. Among the 22 universities, Anna University retains the first rank in WISER Vs PRIMOX and overall web ranking for the year 2016 and 2017. The Tamil Nadu Agricultural University and Annamalai University are sharing the second overall rank. Tamil Nadu National Law School had the last rank in WISER Vs PRIMOX and overall web ranking for the year 2016 and 2017.
4.13 Comparison WISER Vs PRIMOEX Values of Websites of the State Universities in Tamil Nadu for 2017
The WISER Vs PRIMOEX values of Websites of the State Universities in Tamil Nadu for year 2017 were analyzed and the same has been shown in Table 13.
Table 13 describes the Comparison WISER Vs PRIMOEX and web ranking them with the PRIMOEX Values of Websites of the State Universities in Tamil Nadu for the 2017. Comparing with the WISER value with PRIMOEX value the PRIMOEX value is higher than WISER value. Among the 22 universities, all the universities are having more value PRIMOES when comparing the WISER value. When we need a great visibility of the university websites definitely, we must use to use for measuring the PRIMOEX value of ranking. SO, the above shows the value and excellence of the websites of all state universities in Tamil Nadu.
5. Conclusion
The sum up of the ranking of the analysis of the websites of State Universities in Tamil Nadu, while using the WISER and PRIMOEX method it will create the more excellence of the visibility and performance. This study facilitates to know the various ranking standards of websites. The various techniques have been used to rank the websites such as Web Link Structure Analysis, Web Impact Factor, Web ranking, Google Page Rank and Alexa information on Websites for Ranking, WISER Ranking and PRIMOEX Ranking that facilitate the ranking of websites of the State Universities in the Tamil Nadu. As we the library professionals, must create the knowledge and awareness of the PRIMOEX method of the web ranking analysis.
References
- Björneborn, L., & Ingwersen, P. (2004). Toward a basic framework for webometrics. Journal of the American society for information science and technology, 55(14), 1216-1227. [https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.20077]
- Bowler, L., Hong, W. Y., & He, D. (2011). The visibility of health web portals for teens: a hyperlink analysis. Online Information Review, 35(3), 443-470. [https://doi.org/10.1108/14684521111151469]
- Chakravarty, R., & Wasan, S. (2015). Webometric analysis of library websites of higher educational institutes (HEIs) of India: A study through google search Engine. DESIDOC Journal of Library & Information Technology, 35(5). [https://doi.org/10.14429/djlit.35.5.8788]
- Govindarajan, R., & Dhanavandan, S. (2016). Webometric Analysis of Ophthalmology Associations Websites in India. Journal of Advances in Library and Information Science, 5(4), 359-366.
- Huntington, P., Nicholas, D., & Jamali, H. R. (2008). Website usage metrics: A re-assessment of session data. Information Processing & Management, 44(1), 358-372. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ipm.2007.03.003]
- Iroaganachi, M. A., Ilogho, J. E., Itsekor, V., & Osinulu, I. (2016). Research Output and Sustainable Development: Webometric Analysis of Scopus Indexed Publications 2008-2014. Library Philosophy and Practice (e-journal), 1-23.
- Kastania, A. N., & Zimeras, S. (2010). Evaluation for Web-Based Applications. In Web-Based Applications in Healthcare and Biomedicine (pp. 157-166). Springer, Boston, MA. [https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-1274-9_10]
- Thelwall, M., Kousha, K., Dinsmore, A., & Dolby, K. (2015). Alternative metric indicators for funding scheme evaluations. Aslib Journal of Information Management. [https://doi.org/10.1108/AJIM-09-2015-0146]
- Varadharajalu, J., & Dhanavandan, S. (2017). Calculation Web Impact Factor (WIF) for Websites of State University in Telangana, ISST Journal of Advances in Librarianship, 8(1), 1-5.
S. Dhanavandandhanavandan@gmail.com is working as Deputy Librarian, Central Library at Central University of Tamil Nadu, Thiruvarur-610005, Before joining in CUTN, he served as University Assistant Librarian at ‘The Gandhigram Rural Institute – Deemed University’, Gandhigram – 624 302, He has completed M.A. B.Ed., (Economics) DLL & AL., (Law), M.L.I.S, M.Phil, and Ph.D (LIS) in Annamalai University, Annamalai Nagar. He is having more than twenty-one years in the Library and Information Science profession. Six Ph.D degrees were awarded under his guidance. He has published more than 135 articles in National and International Journals and more than 155 papers presented and published in National and International Conferences. He authored more than 33 books in Library and Information Science and 60 Chapters in edited books. He has attended more than 60 Seminars/Workshops and training programmes. He served as Chairperson and Resource Person in many workshops, conferences and also organized fourteen workshops and conferences. He has adjudicated Ten Ph.D theses. He is life of member of SALIS, ALA and MALA.
J. Varadharajalujvaradharajalu@yahoo.com is working as Sr.Assistant Librarian, Central Library at VIT University, Vellore. He did his Ph.D (LIS) in Gandhigram Rural Institute – Deemed University, Gandhigram-624302, Tamil Nadu.. He is having more than twenty 2 years of experience in the Library and Information Science profession. He has published more than 10 articles in National and International Journals and more than 25 papers presented and published in National and International Conferences. He authored more than 1 book in Library and Information Science and 5Chapters in edited books. He has attended more than 20 Seminars/Workshops and training programmes.